UPSC CIVIL SERVICES PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION

UPSC Prelims 2024— Question 15

2024General Studies Paper-IPolity & GovernanceGovernancedifficult
Q15

Question

With reference to Union Budget, consider the following statements: 1. The Union Finance Minister on behalf of the Prime Minister lays the Annual Financial Statement before both the Houses of Parliament. 2. At the Union level, no demand for a grant can be made except on the recommendation of the President of India. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

Options

A
1 only
B
2 only✓ Correct Answer
C
Both 1 and 2
D
Neither 1 nor 2
AnswerOption B

Explanation

The correct answer is option (B). The Annual Financial Statement is laid before Parliament by the President under Article 112; the Finance Minister presents it on behalf of the government, but the constitutional responsibility is not described as the Finance Minister laying it on behalf of the Prime Minister. Demands for grants require the President's recommendation under Article 113. Thus only statement 2 is correct. The key to this question is to distinguish the exact constitutional provision, factual association, scientific principle, or current-affairs detail being tested from statements that are partly true but incomplete or incorrectly framed. UPSC often makes the distractors plausible by changing one institutional role, date, classification, geographic association, or causal relationship. Option A — “1 only” is incorrect. It does not match the established fact or contains the incorrect combination, institution, relationship, classification, or proposition identified in the explanation above. Choosing it would therefore introduce a factual error or omit a necessary element. Option B — “2 only” is correct. It matches the established fact described above and gives the complete combination or identification required by the question. Option C — “Both 1 and 2” is incorrect. It does not match the established fact or contains the incorrect combination, institution, relationship, classification, or proposition identified in the explanation above. Choosing it would therefore introduce a factual error or omit a necessary element. Option D — “Neither 1 nor 2” is incorrect. It does not match the established fact or contains the incorrect combination, institution, relationship, classification, or proposition identified in the explanation above. Choosing it would therefore introduce a factual error or omit a necessary element. For examination purposes, the safest approach is to verify each statement independently before looking at the answer-code combination. This is particularly important in statement-based questions, because one false clause makes an entire combination wrong. In factual questions, compare the defining characteristic asked in the stem with each alternative rather than relying on superficial familiarity. The answer recorded here follows the verified Set C key used for this database.

Question Classification

SubjectPolity & Governance
TopicGovernance
SubtopicTerminal topic
Question TypeStatement-based
Difficultydifficult
VerificationVerified